To Be HONEST

[doyle]

I make an appeal to you, guys.
Judging sigs or avatars made by this forum users, I think we must be honest.
There are a lot of sigs defined "awesome" or "good" etc. etc. but there are NOT so. We must say the truth otherwise people think to be on the right way. To improve ourselves the truth is needed.

[taylor]

your right the people on this forum are to nice to each other

[Jigsaw]

Well, in that case, your sig is awful. I hate it. The people on the bottom, I mean, every single one's head is cut out very very poorly.

[Kartoon]

Well, in that case, your sig is awful. I hate it. The people on the bottom, I mean, every single one's head is cut out very very poorly.

thats cute, except look at the sigs you have all the time....

i think his sig is really good i dig the whole idea of it


and by the way im never real nice about anything i dont like

including jigsaw's current sig

[Cubs On The Red Carpet]

okay ill be more strict from now on
everyone should give constructive criticism
but not slag them off
and doyles sig isn't awful its a great idea and its hot sure maybe the cuts are a lil bit rough but its awesome

[Jigsaw]

Well, in that case, your sig is awful. I hate it. The people on the bottom, I mean, every single one's head is cut out very very poorly.

thats cute, except look at the sigs you have all the time....

i think his sig is really good i dig the whole idea of it


and by the way im never real nice about anything i dont like

including jigsaw's current sig

About time someone said it. My psp7 sigs are so terrible!! And Toon, just cause I said his sig is awful (which I still find true, I'm not going to say I like it just cause you do, like most people do), that doesn't mean I think mine are good. And by the way, yes, the idea of his is infact great. But the cutting.. wow.

[Kartoon]

whatever its still the most creative warriors sig in a long time

so the cutting is off


hey 90% of you "artist" have all kinds of crappy flaws

[Jigsaw]

whatever its still the most creative warriors sig in a long time

so the cutting is off


hey 90% of you "artist" have all kinds of crappy flaws

90% of us artists have 'crappy flaws'? Not 90%, everyone has crappy flaws. Everyone screws up. And most likely to your amazment, you too.

[Cowboy79]

whatever its still the most creative warriors sig in a long time

so the cutting is off


hey 90% of you "artist" have all kinds of crappy flaws

Toon you really can't say that because everyone has flaws in every sig, I haven't seen a signature yet that doesn't have a flaw or someone doesn't like it. I'll straight up admited YOUR signatures sometimes I dislike and sometimes I don't everyone has flaws even you! Plus Doyle also asked for a truthful opinion and Jigsaw just told him how he felt, maybe this past experience will help Doyle make better signatues.

[doyle]

Well, in that case, your sig is awful. I hate it. The people on the bottom, I mean, every single one's head is cut out very very poorly.

Hey ok man, if you hate my sig you're right to tell me that, may be it's not very accurate.
My post is only to "resize" all coments about images and not to trigger a war. All critics are welcome but they must be constructive (CUBS) and not distructive.
More of some pic is a scribble and someone said that's awesome so I asked to express the truth.

[Cubs On The Red Carpet]

whatever its still the most creative warriors sig in a long time

so the cutting is off


hey 90% of you "artist" have all kinds of crappy flaws

Wow. What about when you said this:

by the way review the rules on positive comments

I can understand your frustration when posters don't read and follow the rules, but aren't you breaking one of the rules and going against something you actually said when you make posts like the ones you've made in this thread?

Incidentally, to keep this on topic, I agree that some signatures (and some posts, and some fan fiction entries) are better than others. Not everybody can be the best. That's where, like Cubs suggested, constructive criticism comes in.

Your suggestions don't seem to be constructive, Kartoon. And that's kind of sad, considering how many people on this forum admire your artistic ability.

i agree totally scurvy

Well, in that case, your sig is awful. I hate it. The people on the bottom, I mean, every single one's head is cut out very very poorly.

Hey ok man, if you hate my sig you're right to tell me that, may be it's not very accurate.
My post is only to "resize" all coments about images and not to trigger a war. All critics are welcome but they must be constructive (CUBS) and not distructive.
More of some pic is a scribble and someone said that's awesome so I asked to express the truth.

i agree here as well the? only way anyone can ever improve on this forum is if there told the truth and are given constructive criticism so this would be my comment on doyles sig:

the idea and concept is fantastic and the outlined walking warriors and cleon look great but you could improve it by making the edges around the cuts at the bottom smoother.

stuff like that needs to be said dont just say its awesome or good when it clearly isn't tell them whats good whats bad and what they could improve. and if its really really bad dont completely slag them off tell them and then help them!!!!

so this is how it has to be from now on be honest, constructive but dont slag off.

and im sure after we start doing this EVERYONE will start making better art.

[andy_man]

I totally agree, Some people make something pretty bad and then 15 "Thats Awesome!"'s come behind it. Thats ok but cmon, be truthful. Say whats good what bad and what could be improved.

[Kartoon]

hey kids

im sure you think this revolution to me is cute

but heres what i mean by flaws

i dont mean on a sig by sig base, so get off it

i mean alot of you just suck

feel better?

is that how you want it instead of flaws?


and its a good ammount of you


now, if you wanna say i suck, thats cute...and fine...and you lied to yourself


now bicker as much as you want with each other.....the reality of the whole thing is, as long as most of you have "flaws" your also noobs


oh and by the way i know a bunch of you just tried to take a knock at my karma, lol LOL HAHAHA

go ahead


and next time any of you want to try to pick out my flaws, be able to be better, and in your case CB79 you dont even do art, so get lost

[Kartoon]

whatever its still the most creative warriors sig in a long time

so the cutting is off


hey 90% of you "artist" have all kinds of crappy flaws

Wow. What about when you said this:

by the way review the rules on positive comments

I can understand your frustration when posters don't read and follow the rules, but aren't you breaking one of the rules and going against something you actually said when you make posts like the ones you've made in this thread?

Incidentally, to keep this on topic, I agree that some signatures (and some posts, and some fan fiction entries) are better than others. Not everybody can be the best. That's where, like Cubs suggested, constructive criticism comes in.

Your suggestions don't seem to be constructive, Kartoon. And that's kind of sad, considering how many people on this forum admire your artistic ability.

ok, report me to one of the other mods then, and any one of you other noob bloods who dont like it

[cowboy rules]

Wow, guys come on calm it. I dont really like commenting on sigs because I dont know the first thing about them, but of course everyone has flaws. Now lets not fall fall out here about this, its all about a comment made by doyle, which is totally true of course , about being honest, but I think this has gotten way out of hand. So why dont we all just calm down, and get on with it. Remember most people who voted in my poll 'Why is this Forum so good', and most people said 'Friendly Members' lets not let that slip away now.