Page 1 of 3

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Thu Oct 20, 2005 9:13 pm
by Wonderwheel1979
I like the widescreen, the new packaging... but frankly the new opening is now sort of silly/cheesy
But I do love the movie...oh yes. 8)

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 3:38 am
by Ranchgal
I love the featurettes more than the movie on this disk----when I want the movie, I watch the original disk.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 4:47 am
by Brian
The original cut is better, but the featurettes are well done. I am not as down on the directors cut as some people... its something different.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 5:45 am
by StevenFallonNYC
Simply put, it sucks. I hated it. It was insulting and a disgrace. It's waaay too "in your face," like, "hey viewer, just in case you are too stupid to figure out this film runs like a comic book and in case you haven't heard about it's ancient origins from anyone yet despite the fact that you probably have and that's one reason you wanted to see it, we're gonna shove all of that down your sucker throat to make sure the whole thing isn't lost on you." Screw that. It SUCKED. I can't say it enough. It SUCKED.

The featurettes were pretty decent, and it was good to see the old cast be so into the film and get a kick out of talking about it. I liked that the costume designer mentioned KISS directly as an influence for the Furies. That Furie design with the stars and stripes was horrid. Plenty of great still shots.

But on a one to ten, I'd still just give the whole package a five, because the new cut of the movie SUCKED, and there were no deleted scenes. That is especially a killer.

It also sucks that kids who have heard of The Warriors are only going to have this version available. THat is a freaking crying SHAME and DISGRACE. The hell with Walter Hill for what he did to this magnificent picture.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 5:53 am
by ohs
Yep, Directors cut is for watching featurettes only, original dvd for watching the movie and Cleons cut for watching deleted scenes.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 5:56 am
by JoePal
ohs wrote:Yep, Directors cut is for watching featurettes only, original dvd for watching the movie and Cleons cut for watching deleted scenes.
how about a JoePal's cut of all the cut-scenes of the Rockstar game (including Flashbacks) and replace the game's version of the film to the real film :badgrin:

now, that's a loooong movie!

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Fri Oct 21, 2005 7:29 am
by da-warrior
yer i loved the featurettes but i prefer the original movie,in the australian version we didnt get the deleted scenes did the uk guys or american version get them ?that was my biggest dissapointment :cry:

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2005 1:09 am
by emissary
There is one little thing that both DVD editions have that isn't a real big deal but I noticed it. OK In the opening shot of the wonderwheel, the purple spoke-like lights are now digital looking. On both my VHS copies, one german, the lights are much more "lightbulby" I don't mind the laser look or anything, I just notice it everytime.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2005 4:06 am
by Rem
It drives me nuts that the Director's Cut has better sound, color, and picture quality, but has those darn comic transtitions.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2005 11:45 am
by Ajax Heavy Muscle
I love the new Director's Cut, much better wuality, and the comic book transitions weren't as bad as everyone thinks. It's funny how they claim to be Warriors fans yet they diss the Director's Cut to no end.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2005 12:20 pm
by SoldierHeavyMuscle
Ajax Heavy Muscle wrote:I love the new Director's Cut, much better wuality, and the comic book transitions weren't as bad as everyone thinks. It's funny how they claim to be Warriors fans yet they diss the Director's Cut to no end.
what the hell does that mean???
WHO claims to be warriors fans???
i'm guessin the reason for the dissin, is because of the fact that, every other special edition of every other movie, had twice the extras, of the warriors ultimate directors cut!
(i use the term lightly!!)

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2005 12:23 pm
by GonzoNYC
You beat me too it, SHM! :) Ajax, it is because we are such hardcore fans here that some of us feel a bit cheated by the SE. It is an OK edition but it could have been much more. Only a NON hardcore fan would just accept anything Warrior related thrown at them.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2005 12:48 pm
by SoldierHeavyMuscle
GonzoNYC wrote:You beat me too it, SHM! :) Ajax, it is because we are such hardcore fans here that some of us feel a bit cheated by the SE. It is an OK edition but it could have been much more. Only a NON hardcore fan would just accept anything Warrior related thrown at them.
nice touch, gonz!! ;)

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2005 3:40 pm
by The Fox
Ajax Heavy Muscle wrote:I love the new Director's Cut, much better wuality, and the comic book transitions weren't as bad as everyone thinks. It's funny how they claim to be Warriors fans yet they diss the Director's Cut to no end.
Show some respect Man.

Your joining date is all we need to say.

Amazing how you only appear when the games is just about to be released and the start claiming all sorts of rubbish :roll: :roll:

The Dir's Cut added nothing but a couple of crappy drawn cartoons and not what we had all asked for. The fact we care so much is enough proof.

Do you like the Directors Cut?

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2005 6:05 pm
by Dave Mack
mixed bag for me. Picture and sound are much improved. I do like some of the slow zooms they added, builds tension in certain shots. The beginning is rubbish. I can deal with the comic scenes, they are ok. The Furies one really blows the tension though. Altogether as a "remix" it's ok. But they should have put both versions on the set as they have now taken the original dvd off the market. Meaning that in the future, newcomers will ONLY be able to see the new version.

:) d